[F] Tao Ren vs Dishwasher Safe (Dish wins)

[xavier]

Tao Ren:
image

Dishwasher Safe:
image

Voting to 4.

This battle has been a long time coming so please start voting

[Al Young]

Vote:: Dish

Tao: A little too bright for a desktop wallpaper, in my opinion. The cat also appears to be slightly washed out. I do, however, like the way in which you used the text: as a clip of the image.

Dish: I love it! The monochrome-ish background with the accentuations of colour in the plusses. It's simple and clean and easy on the eyes: everything I go for in a desktop.

[ŖЌǾ]

Vote: Ren

Overall is better than Dish ;D


Sorry

[.t.w.i.l.i.g.h.t.]

I think you need to have more description on what you liked better. More reason behind your vote is going to be needed to make the vote count...

[xavier]

Ahem I'll be the judge of that ;D but yeah RKO's vote doesn't count because there isn't any explanation behind it.

Tao Ren: The green is a bit bright and it's to simple for my likeing. You would have been better off making a larger image rather than a wallpaper because you have space left over, not much more to comment on.

Dishwasher Safe: Ha it's strange the background actually looks like wallpaper this piece is also simple but it has more meaning. It's not too bright like Tao's which is good and I like your logo on the bottom right even though it does get cut off when actually using the image as your background.

My Vote Dish

Dishwasher Safe - 2
Tao Ren - 0

[Psionic]

Tao Ren: I don't know about this one..The fact that it seems personal makes it a good candidate for a wallpaper, but the delivery is a bit...odd? I guess what I'm trying to say is that the position of the cat and text seems a bit out of place and a bit too bright/distracting, considering the rest of the image is plain, empty space (for icons, obviously). I'd suggest reworking the placement of the stocks and text (one of the corners or sides perhaps?) and tone down the brightness just a bit. Again, I like the cat theme.

Dish: A more toned down, yet pleasing wallpaper. I like the background as it gives it a nice, subtle elaborate feel. The vector work in the top corner does its job, but I just don't..get it. Regardless, it's clean and fits the composition. I like the swing and pluses, though.

Vote: Dish
Essentially, it came down to the layout of the wallpaper and I feel that Dish's is cleaner, more elaborate, and in general, the superior wallpaper. Don't get me wrong though, both were good efforts.

[eagle9]

Tao Ren: I seem to agree with everyone else that has voted, in that the green used is too light. It looks like it ruins the overall image, which I would have liked if the green were a different shade, or a different color. Not bad.

Dishwasher Safe: I liked this image. Even though it looks simple, it has significance. I think you could have done without the plus signs at the bottom of the image, though. I think that ruined the whole black and white theme you had.

Vote: Dishwasher Safe

[.t.w.i.l.i.g.h.t.]

Good job Dish... we shall due battle soon. This time... I go balls to the walls.

[cypher]

I will happily battle you again.