[F] Eagle vs. x.ica (x.ica wins)

[x.ica]

x.ica vs Eagle

x.ica -


Eagle -


First to five votes.

[eagle9]

Well, I am certainly not an expert yet, but I think I can do this. It's worth a try, right?

[x.ica]

Of course it is.

When would you like to set the due date for?

[eagle9]

I already completed my image, so whenever you're ready.

[x.ica]

I'll have mine done tonight as well. Feel free to post yours now.

Oops.

Done!



It's Bob Marley. xD

[eagle9]

Dang. Nice work. Haha. Here's mine:

i85.photobucket.com/albums/k43/phoenix617/Freestyle/PanicAttheDisco.jpg

Panic! At the Disco


I think we can open it up for voting, now.

[x.ica]

Now we just need to have it moved.

[eagle9]

Alright, it was moved! And so the voting begins!

[x.ica]

Sounds good.

Good luck to you hon.

[Release || Syndrome]

I vote for x.ica due to the fact that Eagle's sig is vaguely plain, and i dislike the sunburst over the white text, it makes is confusing at that point. Also x.ica has a _very_ nice effect on her's, so thusly, i vote for x.ica

[gray929]

Eagle -This signature isn't your best work. First, the sun bolt is the default one if you know what I mean. There are options to lower the opacity of the circles and rays. The rays seem too sharp thus making the sig look bad. The whole signature overall seems unorganized. Instead of a black bg, at least use a brush. Next, I don't like the border. The render would look much better if it wasn't covered by text and inside the border. Black + white isn't an appealing color scheme. Very simple and need some work. Sorry if I came off as a b!tch. It's just one bad one out of many good ones you have made!

x.ica- I love the grungy style. It would look better if you had some contrast in this. Maybe soften parts of it. The black dots are a bit to evident so I'd tone down that color or blend it more. But, the render is blended very, very well. Last, I like how you decided not to add text on this. Excellent job on this!

My Vote: x.ica

[eagle9]

I know, I'm kind of new to this graphics thing.

Eagle: 0
x.ica: 2

[gray929]

eagle9 said:

I know, I'm kind of new to this graphics thing.

Eagle: 0
x.ica: 2

eh, no worries bro. At least you are trying to get betta. I know tons of people who try to make a sig once and fail. Then, they throw out their graphics program and yadayada.

[xavier]

Eagle: I don't feel much like criticizing today so I'll just say it looks un-organized and the poor text and border lets it down also moving it off the stock would be better.

x.ica: I did not like how you decided not to add text to the sig, I just think you've over done it there is too much going on you've over complicated it and the stock isn't very conspicuous.

My vote x.ica

Eagle - 0
x.ica - 3

[Admin]

I'm going to close this at 4 votes, since it has been open a while.

My vote goes to x.ica

I liked the colours, although there isn't a great deal of variety here, I must say. I thought some text might have worked well here also. The texture is rather good.

Eagle, I would remove the sunburst effect you have here, whilst being a feature in paintshop pro or photoshop, they are very rarely used and the effect isn't that appealing to me. Try placing your text on the same line and try to keep the font sizes and style the same. Maybe see if you can add some texture, like x.ica has done. There are various stock images that can help you out in doing this.

X.ica wins with 4 votes.