[F] Jack v. Oliver

[Jack]

Yar.

Size: 1024x768
Theme: Whatever you want.
Due: Tuesday

First to five.


Here's mine.

www.deviantart.com/view/17935588/

[Admin]

Here we go:
www.deviantart.com/view/17911224/

[Jack]

Ok, done. Let's get some votes guys!

[Admin]

Nice entry there jack!

[egbakaet :D]

Oliver: Great mountains I love the towering effect it portrays. Nice Job! ;D ;D ;D

Jack: I really like yours. The texture and lighting effects are great! I love this too.

Vote: Oliver

Good luck guys!

[Jack]

Thankks for the vote, keep them coming.

[killaklown]

Ooohhh, nice nice!

Oliver: Very nice, I like the mountain scene, the little pool in the middle is pretty cool. But, I think the colour scheme is a bit dull.

Jack: Yous looks more realistic, Ollie's looks a bit more computerised, lol. The colours are nice, the sky and the mountains both blend nicely together.

You both put together some very nice work! Congrats!
Vote: Jack

[Sev]

My Vote: Jack

Reasoning:

This one was hard for me to vote on. Normally I look at each person's piece and decide who's is better based on quality, style, and all that stuff, but I couldn't judge this one like that.

Both pieces are great, I have no idea how Terragen works, but both images look damn cool.

However, I like Jack's better because to me it looks more realistic. The texture of the ground looks better than the darker green texture in Olllie's, which almost looks too green. I like how the ground in Jack's looks a little burnt out, it reminds me of the hills in the Lord of the Rings movies (filmed in New Zealand ?). Also, the water in Ollie's looks weird. I don't know if that's his fault or the program's, but either way it doesn't look that real.

Anyhow, good job to both of you, it was tough to judge.

[iggy!]

My vote: Jack

Nice from both of you.

Jack: Great stuff here. I love the grass and the amount of detail on the grass. The sky I really like on this work. The orange and white sky goes great with this piece. I really don't think the lighting sucks that bad. I think you did a great job with it . Although on the far right side I have to say that the grass looks fake and much more detail could of been put into that side. Other than that great work.

Oliver: I really don't enjoy this piece as much as Jack's. It seems pretty bland with the blue and green. I think much work could of gone into the sky just lighting it up a little bit. I think putting a little more white in the sky would of looked nice. Having a blue and then as moving up more of a white. The hills with the pool was a great idea. The hills however seem a little fake. As others have said this looks more computerised. The water here looks okay. A small glance and someone will see just a blue area while in a very detailed look you can see the waves and such. I didn't think it looked too bad but it didn't stand out enough. The blue on the side of the mountains looks quite strange. Somewhat like koolaid. lol. It does though. This is a great idea but could be worked on .

I thought both of these works were great. I have no idea how to use Terragen so hats of to you guys .

[Jack]

Thanks for the votes, current standing is 3-1.

[[ƒA§T]ER 3200+]

Jack- I like the way your mountains look. The shape, the grass, everything. The lighting is very nice imo, bright, but not overpowering. It might have been nice if there had been some water like in Ollie's piece, but it looks great as is.
Ollie- Nice shaping of the mountains Ollie, the whole sort of bowl effect works very well. The texture on the mountains could be better though, it just seems somewhat cheesy. The sky and lighting are fine imo, and the clouds are a nice tough.
My vote- Jack

[Jack]

Thanks for the vote, 4-1

[Beam]

Vote: Oliver

The angle captured in oliver's is nicely done and the shadow looked good in the picture. It was a nice piece.

[Admin]

4-2 now

Though I think Jack has this one in the bag.

Thanks for the vote beam.

[Jack]

Nice battle, anyway

[Mitchell]

Last Vote: Jack

Jack: i love what youve done with the sky, wonderful colors, and the grass is very well done.

Oliver: A nice image, but the terrain just seems to smooth in my opinion, ad the clouds are just too dark for my liking. A great image,i just dont like it's concept as much as Jack's

[joea]

Very nice battle, you 2. Both pieces were of high quality.

[joea]

D-I-D data recorded, thanks for participating!!